Ramaphosa tells Musk to give back: what it means for Starlink in SA
Ramaphosa urged Elon Musk to give back to South Africa, and Musk replied that SA is now super racist against Whites and Asians. Here is what each said and why Starlink is still not licensed here.

President Cyril Ramaphosa has urged Elon Musk to "give back" to South Africa, saying the education Musk got here helped make him who he is. Musk replied on X on 17 November that "South Africa is now super racist against Whites and Asians". The exchange is really about one thing South Africans keep asking about: why Starlink still is not licensed here (Semafor, Business Insider Africa).
What did Ramaphosa say?
Ramaphosa was speaking to ABC News correspondent Jonathan Karl at Semafor's Silicon Valley & The World event in California on 16 November (ITWeb). He said:
- Musk "has not really" grasped the harm apartheid did, and that the apartheid government spent R12 on Musk's education for every R1 it spent on his (The National).
- Musk should be one of those who say they want to contribute to South Africa's development and "give back to this country that made me who I am today" (TimesLIVE).
- The two had talked about meeting on this trip, but their diaries did not line up (TimesLIVE).
How did Musk respond?
Musk replied to a clip of the interview on X on 17 November: "South Africa is now super racist against Whites and Asians" (Business Insider Africa, Briefly News). He has previously called South Africa's empowerment laws "openly racist" and described them as "apartheid 2.0" (The National, Semafor).
Why is Starlink not available in South Africa?
The sticking point is ownership. Telecoms licence holders in South Africa must have at least 30% of the local operation owned by historically disadvantaged groups, under the B-BBEE framework (The National, Semafor). Musk says this is why Starlink cannot operate here. Ramaphosa said there have been talks, that Musk "has had difficulty in understanding the policy position", and that every country sets its own rules for foreign companies (TimesLIVE).
| Point | Ramaphosa's position | Musk's position |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership rule | Foreign firms must follow local policy, as in any country | Calls the laws racist |
| Starlink licence | Talks have happened, the policy stands | Says it is blocked because of race rules |
| Apartheid legacy | Redress is needed for unequal spending | Calls the current system "apartheid 2.0" |
Sources: Semafor, The National, TimesLIVE.
Starlink is still not authorised in South Africa, nearly six years after pre-orders opened (Business Insider Africa). If you use a Starlink kit here, Reported has explained the rules on cut-offs and registration.
Why was Ramaphosa in Silicon Valley?
He is leading a delegation of about 300 South Africans, including ministers, 27 postgraduate students and about 24 start-ups, on a four-day visit to draw investment and skills in artificial intelligence (The National).
FAQ
What did Ramaphosa say to Elon Musk?
He urged Musk to give back to South Africa, saying the education Musk received here helped shape his success, and said Musk does not fully understand the harm apartheid did.
How did Musk reply to Ramaphosa?
On 17 November Musk wrote on X that South Africa is now super racist against Whites and Asians.
Why is Starlink not licensed in South Africa?
Telecoms licence holders must have at least 30% local ownership by historically disadvantaged groups. Musk objects to the rule and Starlink has not been authorised.
Did Ramaphosa meet Musk in Silicon Valley?
No. Ramaphosa said there was talk of a meeting, but their diaries did not line up.