Government

Hill-Lewis for Joburg mayor, Zille back to Cape Town? The swap plan

The DA's Geordin Hill-Lewis has floated becoming Johannesburg mayor while Helen Zille returns to Cape Town, to win ActionSA's support, the Sunday Times reports. What was said, and the seat maths.

By Reported Team

Geordin Hill-Lewis and Helen Zille side by side, labelled Joburg mayor swap plan
Left: Democratic Alliance staff photographer, CC BY-SA 3.0 ZA. Right: Democratic Alliance on Flickr, CC BY-SA 2.0. Both via Wikimedia Commons (cropped, combined, text added)

DA leader Geordin Hill-Lewis has floated swapping jobs with Helen Zille: he would become mayor of Johannesburg and she would return to Cape Town as mayor. The aim is to win over ActionSA, which refuses to back Zille in Joburg, the Sunday Times reported on Tuesday, 17 November (TimesLIVE).

Several sources in both parties told the paper the idea had been put to ActionSA's leaders. It is not a done deal. Hill-Lewis neither confirmed nor denied it, and Zille said she did not "put much store by it" (TimesLIVE).

What exactly is being proposed?

NowUnder the reported swap
Geordin Hill-LewisCape Town mayorJohannesburg mayor
Helen ZilleDA's Johannesburg mayoral candidateCape Town mayor

Source: Sunday Times sources, via TimesLIVE. Unconfirmed by the DA.

A senior DA insider told the paper the swap was one of several options to break the deadlock and would lock the ANC out of the Gauteng metros if it led to a DA and ActionSA deal. Another DA source said Zille's removal was "no longer a red line" but "a discussion point", and noted that Hill-Lewis was born and raised in Johannesburg (TimesLIVE).

What did Hill-Lewis, Zille and ActionSA say?

  • Hill-Lewis: "We don't negotiate in the media. All options are on the table" (TimesLIVE).
  • Zille confirmed she had heard the speculation but dismissed it (TimesLIVE).
  • ActionSA chairperson Michael Beaumont didn't confirm the swap. He said ActionSA would be open to coalition talks in Joburg, Tshwane and elsewhere "should the DA help to address this problem" (TimesLIVE).

ActionSA has said its problem is not with the DA as a party but with Zille in Joburg and Cilliers Brink in Tshwane (TimesLIVE).

Would a DA and ActionSA deal have enough seats in Joburg?

Not quite on its own. Johannesburg's council has 270 seats, so a mayor needs 136 votes.

CombinationSeatsMajority (136)?
DA + ActionSA134No, 2 short
DA + ActionSA + FF Plus139Yes
ANC + ActionSA106No, 30 short
DA + ANC154Yes

Seats: DA 91, ANC 63, ActionSA 43, FF Plus 5, from IEC results via Rateweb. Totals are Reported's calculation.

So even with ActionSA on board, the DA would still need at least one smaller party, such as the FF Plus, to get a mayor elected.

Why does the ANC's offer matter here?

The swap idea surfaced on the same day EWN reported that the ANC had sent ActionSA a letter offering it the mayors of both Johannesburg (Herman Mashaba) and Tshwane (Nasiphi Moya), with the ANC keeping Ekurhuleni (EWN; Reported). EWN also understands the DA sent its own proposal. ActionSA now has to choose between the two (EWN).

A DA source told the Sunday Times its talks with the ANC had stalled (TimesLIVE).

Could Hill-Lewis legally become Joburg mayor?

The report does not explain how the swap would work. Councils elect a mayor from among their own councillors (Business Day), so whoever is elected Joburg mayor must hold a seat on the Johannesburg council. The report also doesn't say how Zille would return to the Cape Town job.

The timing is tight. Cape Town's new council sits on Thursday, 19 November, at 10:00 (City of Cape Town), and Johannesburg and Tshwane are also expected to sit on Thursday, though neither has confirmed it (Sunday Times).

FAQ

Is Geordin Hill-Lewis becoming Johannesburg mayor?

Not confirmed. The Sunday Times reported on 17 November 2026 that he floated swapping places with Helen Zille. He neither confirmed nor denied it, and Zille dismissed the speculation.

Why won't ActionSA back Helen Zille?

ActionSA says its problem is not with the DA as a party but with Zille as Johannesburg mayoral candidate and Cilliers Brink in Tshwane.

How many seats does the DA need for a Joburg mayor?

A mayor needs 136 of the council's 270 votes. The DA has 91 and ActionSA 43, so together they are 2 short and would need a party such as the FF Plus (5 seats).

When does Johannesburg's new council sit?

Johannesburg and Tshwane are expected to sit on Thursday 19 November 2026, but neither city has confirmed the date. Cape Town sits that day at 10:00.

Sources