Does Joburg's mayor need 136 votes? How the secret ballot works
Joburg's next mayor needs a majority of votes cast by councillors at the meeting: 136 if all 270 vote. How the secret ballot, knockout rounds and ties work before the 19 November sittings.

Not quite. A mayor is elected by secret ballot and needs a majority of the votes cast by the councillors at the meeting, not a fixed share of all seats (Dullah Omar Institute; Buffalo City standing rules). If every one of Johannesburg's 270 councillors votes, that is 136. If some stay away, the winning number drops.
That matters this week. Johannesburg and Tshwane are expected to hold their first sittings on Thursday, 19 November, with no coalition deal announced yet (Sunday Times).
How does the vote for mayor work?
Schedule 3 of the Municipal Structures Act sets the procedure, and councils repeat it in their standing rules. Buffalo City's published rules set it out like this (Buffalo City standing rules):
| Step | What happens |
|---|---|
| Nominations | The presiding officer reads out the names. No debate is allowed |
| One candidate | That candidate is declared elected with no vote |
| Two or more candidates | A secret ballot is held and each councillor present gets one vote |
| Someone gets a majority | That candidate is declared mayor |
| Nobody gets a majority | The candidate with the fewest votes is knocked out and councillors vote again, until someone has a majority |
| Two left and tied | A further meeting is held within 7 days and the vote is repeated |
The speaker is elected the same way, and so are the chief whip and other office-bearers (Buffalo City standing rules). The speaker is elected first (Inside Politics).
How many votes does each metro's mayor need?
| Metro | Seats | Votes needed if every councillor votes | Largest party |
|---|---|---|---|
| Johannesburg | 270 | 136 | DA, 91 |
| Ekurhuleni | 224 | 113 | DA, 66 |
| eThekwini | 223 | 112 | MK, 86 |
| Tshwane | 214 | 108 | DA, 74 |
Sources: Rateweb Johannesburg, Ekurhuleni, eThekwini and Tshwane, from IEC results files.
The Dullah Omar Institute describes the rule as 50% plus one of the votes of the councillors present (Dullah Omar Institute). So by Reported's calculation, if 10 of Johannesburg's councillors were absent, a candidate would need 131 of the 260 votes instead of 136.
Can a mayor win without a coalition majority?
Yes, on the day. Because the ballot is secret, councillors can vote against their party's line, and a candidate only has to beat the others in the room. A deal that adds up on paper can still lose if a few councillors stay away or vote the other way.
Governing afterwards is harder. Budgets and other council decisions still need majority support, which is why parties are chasing deals that reach 136 in Johannesburg (African Bulletin 24).
Has this happened before?
In Cape Town's 2021 first sitting, Geordin Hill-Lewis was elected with 141 votes against 46 for the ANC's candidate and 2 for the Cape Independence Party's, with 15 spoilt ballots and 20 abstentions (News24).
What happens next?
Johannesburg and Tshwane are expected to sit on 19 November, Cape Town confirmed that date, and eThekwini and other KZN hung councils sit in the week of 23 November. Reported has this week's council meeting dates and the Joburg, Tshwane and Ekurhuleni seat maths.
FAQ
How many votes does the Johannesburg mayor need?
A majority of the votes cast by councillors present. If all 270 vote, that is 136.
Is the vote for mayor secret?
Yes. When more than one candidate is nominated, councillors vote by secret ballot.
What happens if no candidate for mayor gets a majority?
The candidate with the fewest votes is knocked out and councillors vote again until someone has a majority.
What if two mayoral candidates tie?
If the last two candidates have the same number of votes, a further meeting is held within seven days and the vote is repeated.
Sources
- Buffalo City: Standing Rules and Orders for Council By-law (LawLibrary)
- Dullah Omar Institute: Agenda for the first council meeting
- Inside Politics: How new municipal councils will be formed
- Sunday Times: Trading to settle metros
- News24: Hill-Lewis inaugurated as Cape Town mayor (2021)
- African Bulletin 24: Joburg mayor fact check, 136 seats
- Rateweb: Johannesburg results
- Rateweb: Ekurhuleni results
- Rateweb: eThekwini results
- Rateweb: Tshwane results