Government

Court sets aside 3 eThekwini top-manager hires. What happens now

The Durban High Court has set aside eThekwini's appointment of three executive directors, finding the council broke hiring rules and acted in bad faith. The City is studying the ruling.

By Reported Team

A wooden judge's gavel resting on a sound block
Photo: Chris Potter via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

The Durban High Court has set aside eThekwini Municipality's appointment of three senior managers, declaring the council's decision invalid, unlawful and inconsistent with the Constitution. Judge Sanele Hlatshwayo delivered the judgment on 10 November 2026, a year after the council approved the appointments.

The City says its lawyers are studying the ruling and it will not comment yet, The Mercury reports.

Which posts are affected?

PostAppointee
Executive director: Operations ManagementLindokuhle Mkhize
Executive director: Public SafetyCyril Bhekinkosi Mkhize
Executive director: Technical ServicesEdnick Msweli

Source: Durban High Court judgment, case 2025-235254 and IOL.

The council approved the three on 13 November 2025 on its executive committee's recommendation. Municipal manager Musa Mbhele then directed that they start on 15 November 2025, according to The Mercury. The DA brought the review application.

Why did the court set the appointments aside?

The court found the council itself broke the rules for hiring senior managers under section 56 of the Municipal Systems Act. The judgment lists:

  • improper screening, with screening reports dated 15 October 2025 even though some screening was finished only after interviews
  • the council failing to satisfy itself that the legal requirements for the appointments were met
  • appointing a public safety head who did not hold the law or safety and security degree the post advertised
  • appointing the technical services head without dealing with negative Auditor-General findings
  • the council acting in bad faith

The judge also pointed to the council asking, on 4 December 2025, for the Cogta minister to approve higher salaries of R2,916,751 a year for each of the three. That was less than a month after they started, and well above the advertised pay. The court said the council gave no explanation, which suggested the outcome was "a foregone conclusion", The Mercury and the judgment say.

The court did not uphold every complaint. It rejected the DA's argument that two other candidates were unfairly excluded.

Why didn't the court keep them in place to avoid disruption?

The City asked the court to preserve the appointments for continuity and to avoid disruption to services. The judge said section 56(2) of the Systems Act makes an appointment that breaks the Act null and void, and that a fundamentally flawed process should be set aside, not salvaged, the judgment says.

Who pays the legal costs?

The council, Mayor Cyril Xaba, the municipal manager and the three appointees must pay the DA's costs jointly, including two counsel, News24 reports. Each side pays its own costs for the earlier urgent application.

The court also declared that councillors did not break the councillors' code of conduct by using information from closed council sessions to bring the review.

What happens now?

The City has not said whether it will appeal. Its only response so far is that its legal team is studying the judgment, The Mercury reports.

The ruling lands as eThekwini's new council prepares to sit. No party has a majority on the 223-seat council, and the MK Party, DA, ANC and IFP are still in coalition talks, the Sunday Tribune reports. Councils must hold their first sitting within 14 days of the IEC gazetting councillors' names on 13 November, SAnews reports.

FAQ

Which eThekwini appointments did the court set aside?

The council's November 2025 appointment of the executive directors for Operations Management, Public Safety and Technical Services.

When was the judgment delivered?

Judge Sanele Hlatshwayo delivered it electronically in the Durban High Court on 10 November 2026.

Will eThekwini appeal?

The City has not said. It says its legal representatives are studying the judgment and it will not comment yet.

Sources