Government

How ANC's Masuku could become Joburg deputy mayor without a seat

ActionSA offered to free up PR list places in Joburg, Tshwane and Ekurhuleni for ANC leaders who have no council seats, a senior ANC leader told the Sunday Times. Here is how a PR seat changes hands and what it means for Thursday's votes.

By Reported Team

ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba speaking at an event, with the label Joburg seat offer
Photo: St. Gallen Symposium, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped, text added)

ActionSA has offered to take at least one of its own councillors off its party lists in Johannesburg, Tshwane and Ekurhuleni so that ANC leaders who lost out on council seats can get in, a senior ANC leader told the Sunday Times. In Johannesburg, that could put the ANC's Loyiso Masuku in line for deputy mayor, the leader said.

The offer has not been confirmed by ActionSA, and no coalition deal has been announced in any Gauteng metro. Johannesburg and Tshwane are expected to hold their first council sittings, where the speaker and mayor are elected, on Thursday, 19 November (Sunday Times).

What exactly is ActionSA reported to have offered?

According to the ANC leader, ActionSA brought a document to the talks and said it had agreed with the ANC's Gauteng leader Panyaza Lesufi to "remove from their PR lists at least one person in the three metros to make space for ANC people" (Sunday Times).

MetroReported mayor under the planWhat the ANC would get through ActionSA's list
JohannesburgActionSARoom for Loyiso Masuku to become deputy mayor, plus one person for a mayoral committee (MMC) post
TshwaneActionSAOne or two places for a deputy mayor and an MMC
EkurhuleniANCOne place for a person of the ANC's choosing, who would become mayor

Source: a senior ANC leader quoted by the Sunday Times. Not confirmed by ActionSA.

"How can we say no to that?" the ANC NEC member told the paper, saying the offer made it hard for ANC members who oppose working with ActionSA to turn it down (Sunday Times).

Why does the ANC need someone else's seats?

The ANC won no proportional representation (PR) seats in any of the three metros. Its 63 seats in Johannesburg, 44 in Tshwane and 59 in Ekurhuleni all came from wards (Daily Maverick).

That happened because the party won more wards than its share of the vote entitled it to, so its PR list was never used. Masuku was first on the ANC's Johannesburg list and outgoing mayor Dada Morero fourth, and neither returns to council. In Ekurhuleni, the ANC's mayoral candidate Jongizizwe Dlabathi and outgoing mayor Nkosindiphile Xhakaza are also out (News24).

This matters because a council can only elect its executive mayor and deputy mayor "from among its members" (Municipal Structures Act, section 55). An ANC source told Daily Maverick the party was "on the back foot" in talks because it had no one from its own list to put forward (Daily Maverick).

How would a PR seat change hands?

PR seats belong to the party list, not to a ward, so a party can fill a vacancy with someone new from its list. The rules sit in Schedule 1 of the Municipal Structures Act (GetLawED, Schedule 1):

StepWhat the law says
A PR councillor leaves officeThe chief electoral officer declares the person at the top of that party's list elected (item 18)
The party changes its listA party may "supplement, change or increase its list at any time" and must give the IEC the amended list (item 20)
DeadlineThe party has up to 21 days after the councillor leaves to change the list, and the seat must be filled within 14 days after that (item 20)
Who can stay on a listA candidate drops off a list if they stop being a member of the party that listed them (item 19)

Source: Municipal Structures Act, Schedule 1, items 18 to 20.

Neither the Sunday Times nor Daily Maverick explained how party membership would work for an ANC leader placed on another party's list. Until a seat actually changes hands and the person is sworn in, they can't be elected deputy mayor or mayor.

Is the SACP another route?

The ANC has also looked to its alliance partner. The SACP holds PR seats in all three metros: two in Johannesburg, three in Tshwane and two in Ekurhuleni. An insider told Daily Maverick the SACP was expected to make room for one ANC-aligned candidate on its list per council, which could see Masuku elected as an SACP PR councillor (Daily Maverick).

The SACP said the opposite last week. Acting spokesperson Mhlekwa Nxumalo told the Mail & Guardian that its councillors had been chosen by communities and "we are not going to enter any negotiations regarding those changes" (Mail & Guardian).

The other option is for the ANC to use one of its own ward councillors as deputy mayor, speaker or chair of chairs, The Citizen reported.

Would ANC and ActionSA have a majority on their own?

No. Together they fall short in all three metros and would still need smaller parties (Daily Maverick).

MetroANC seatsActionSA seatsTogetherNeeded for a majority
Johannesburg6343106136 of 270
Tshwane444892108 of 214
Ekurhuleni594099113 of 224

Sources: Daily Maverick for the ANC seats, combined totals and majorities; Sunday Times for ActionSA's Tshwane and Ekurhuleni seats; Rateweb, IEC results for ActionSA's Johannesburg seats.

Is a DA deal still possible?

Yes. Mashaba told IOL his party has "a Helen Zille and Cilliers Brink problem", not a DA problem, and would back the DA in Johannesburg and Ekurhuleni if the DA supports Nasiphi Moya for Tshwane mayor (IOL). The Sunday Times reported the DA is considering moving its leader Geordin Hill-Lewis from Cape Town to stand for Johannesburg mayor, which he would neither confirm nor deny (Sunday Times).

The ANC is expected to brief the media on its coalition talks on Wednesday, 18 November (EWN). Reported will update this article when the parties confirm a deal or the first sittings take place.

FAQ

Can Loyiso Masuku become Johannesburg deputy mayor?

Only if she first becomes a councillor. The ANC won no PR seats in Johannesburg, so she has no seat. A senior ANC leader told the Sunday Times that ActionSA offered to make room on its PR list so she could become deputy mayor, but ActionSA has not confirmed this.

Why did the ANC get no PR seats in Joburg, Tshwane and Ekurhuleni?

It won more wards than its share of the vote entitled it to, so its party list was not used. All its seats in the three metros come from wards.

Can a party give its council seat to someone else?

A PR seat is filled from the party's list. If a PR councillor leaves office, the party may change its list within 21 days and the seat must be filled within 14 days after that, under Schedule 1 of the Municipal Structures Act.

When will Johannesburg and Tshwane elect their mayors?

The Sunday Times reported that both are expected to hold their first council sittings on Thursday, 19 November 2026, where the speaker and mayor are elected.

Sources